Escape Academy 2 red herring collectibles are the treasured creature from the first game, and this time there are no tricks with them: the developers are hiding more than 50 all over campus. You collect them and hand them in to Cod Stewart, and the achievement Herring Is Caring asks you to turn in all 50.
Escape Academy 2 red herring collectibles: where they hide
Three areas are named as Red Herring spots:
- Campus Gardens — finding some Red Herrings is listed as one of the things the area is good for, right next to its Extra Credit quests. The Campus Gardens maze guide covers the other thing that area hides.
- Arts Campus — the developers list Red Herrings among what you can expect to find there, next to Escape Bucks and Extra Credit. It is a large area with the Hall of Escapists & Workshop, the Monument of Escape, the Costume Shop, the Dance Studio and the Theater in it, so there is a lot of ground to cover.
- The Headmaster's office — the Red Herring on the bookshelf near the Headmaster's office is now pickable. The June 2026 demo patch notes record that change, because the pick-up had been unavailable there before. If you tried it in an older build and could not take it, try again.
The rest are scattered without a published list, so the way to sweep the school is area by area rather than marker by marker.

Turning them in
Red Herrings are collected and then handed in to Cod Stewart, and the count is what the achievement tracks. That is the whole loop: find one, pick it up, turn it in.
Because they are spread over the campus rather than concentrated in one place, the practical order is to clear one area properly before moving to the next, and to check the small spaces — bookshelves, offices and corners of rooms are where the ones near the Headmaster's office have turned up. The campus map guide lists the areas and the gates, so you know how many you can actually reach right now.
Red Herrings are not spendable Bucks
It is worth being clear about this, because the two collectibles sit side by side in the same rooms: a Red Herring is not currency. You cannot spend one on a class book, on a story item or on a zipline ride, and picking one up does not move the critical path forward. What it does is move you closer to the Herring Is Caring achievement.
The currency that does get spent is Escape Bucks, and those have a whole set of prices attached to them. The Escape Bucks guide covers what they buy and where they come from.