Annihilated which partner to pick comes down to what you want out of the run: the Mage knows the dungeon and explains things, the Warrior lets you take several weapons in one go, the Hero plays like a slightly better protagonist but is weak on information and sanity, and the Priest is the hardest of the four to reach, because he only appears once you have lost a run.

Annihilated which partner to pick: what players report

PartnerWhat players report after their own runs
The MageThe one who knows the dungeon and explains things while you are down there
The WarriorThe one that lets you steal multiple weapons in one go
The HeroRoughly a slightly better protagonist, but weak on information and sanity
The PriestA bad outcome, and the one you cannot pick on your first run

The announcement for the character trailers only asks "Who will you choose?" without ranking them, so the comparison that actually helps is what players report back. For what each of them lost and how they fight next to you, the companion roster has the full picture.

How to unlock the Priest route

At the start of a run only three partners are offered, and the Priest is not one of them. The rule that opens him up is short:

  • Lose a run first.
  • The Priest is then waiting when you pick your partner for the next attempt.

Because a death sends you back to the floor where you fell rather than to the top of the dungeon, reaching the Priest route costs one extra attempt rather than one extra minute. The demo applies the same rule even though it contains all four routes, so you can play his opening stretch in the demo too — you just have to fail once to get him.

What that death leaves behind is worth knowing before you spend it, and the after a death guide covers where you restart and which parts of the run survive.

Why the choice binds the run

You can only carry one of them out. Choose your partner, and escape together.

That is a run-level decision, not a menu you can change later: the companion you walk out with is the one whose story you are playing, and the other three stay behind. It is also the reason the Priest is worth planning around — his route is a route like any other, you simply have to fail your way into it.